Pre-empting proliferation : international law, morality and nuclear weapons / Michael J. Glennon
Document type:
Article
Title:
Pre-empting proliferation : international law, morality and nuclear weapons
Author zone:
Michael J. Glennon
Host item entries:
Languages:
English
General Note:
Contribution dans le cadre du symposium : Just and unjust warriors : marking the 35th anniversary of Walzer's Just and unjust wars
Abstract:
Michael Walzer is right that dwelling on the United Nations Charter's use-of-force rules constitutes 'utopian quibbling'. But he is wrong that 'practical morality' of the sort defended in his Just and Unjust Wars presents a useful analytic framework for addressing issues such as the advisability of using force to counter threats of nuclear proliferation. Walzer’s moral evaluations do not meet the standard of consistency that he himself demands, and the foundational inconsistency of his moral appraisals produces the same context-oriented relativism that he rejects. Policy analysis offers a preferable approach because it makes fewer assumptions. Its vocabulary interposes no problematic metaphysical infrastructure between ends and means, and it generates no debate that is not directly pertinent to the decision at hand. However, neither international law, practical morality, nor a consequentialist calculus of national interest can eliminate the need for judicious choice and subjective judgement.
Links:
Authors:
Keyword in English:
Keyword in French:
Go to: