Article

Jungle justice : passing sentence on the equality of belligerents in non-international armed conflict

Jonathan Somer

• International review of the Red Cross, Vol. 89, no. 867, September 2007, p. 655-690

English

A special challenge posed by the international humanitarian law (IHL) principle of equality of belligerents in the context of non-international armed conflict is the capacity of armed opposition groups to pass sentences on individuals for acts related to the hostilities. Today this situation is conflated by the concurrent application of international human rights and criminal law. The fair trial provisions of IHL can incorporate their human rights equivalents either qua human rights law or by analogy, recognizing that human rights law does not account for the anomalous relationship between a state and non-state party. It is argued that the preferred solution is the latter. This would put greater focus on the actual fairness of insurgent courts rather than on their legal basis. Moreover, it would be consistent with the equality of belligerents principle, a vital condition to encourage IHL compliance by armed opposition groups.

• Full text

• International review of the Red Cross / ICRC
• International review of the Red Cross [Vol. 89, no. 867, September 2007] / ICRC